Nicola Pizza in Rehoboth Beach

Ordered a dozen frozen Nicoboli’s to take to Florida. Put them in a cooler with ice packs. After 16 hours on the road they arrived still frozen! Put them in the fridge to thaw overnight and baked them for dinner that night. They were delicious!! Now our Florida families want us to bring them every time we visit. Thanks Nicola’s for being there during the pandemic!!

The best pizza. I was raised here in Delaware. And I haven't been there in along time. The pizza is awesome.

New to the area, searching for decent pizza, and happened upon Nicola by chance.... thanking my lucky stars i did !!! It's delicious, it really is. A lovely mild sauce, perfect amount of cheese, and incredible crust, combined for the perfect slice. You've gotta try it !!!

Try everything on the menu..it's all delicious. I've enjoyed pizza and spaghetti and meat balls. Had samples of several dishes from dining friends. Decor is lovely and adds to the dining pleasure. Server was friendly and service was quick and accurate.Reasonably priced with plenty to share.

Family owned restaurant serving classic Italian dishes featuring their namesake the Ni-O-Boli!I had the loaded Mac and added spinach and hot sauce! Yum!Dishes are LARGE, salad is enough for 2 or 3!Plan for leftovers!Clean facilities, friendly accommodating waiters and staff, delicious food!The only thing I could mark down on was it took someone at my table of six 15 minutes beyond the rest of us to receive just OK spaghetti with meatballs.Other than that, all we pleased.

The people were very nice, the place seemed to be taken care of well, they accidentally did something to our pizza which took longer but it was definitely worth the wait. 10/10 place

Thus is a must in town! Great food and service plus a train track! Gotta go!

Visiting Rehoboth and were told rave things about Nicola’s and it didn’t disappoint. Food was delicious and price was as expected. The decor isn’t anything special but they do have a cute model train that runs on a track around the top of the restaurant. Our initial server was not good but the other servers made up for it. We went for an early dinner but I’m sure it gets packed around meals.

Great pizza, great service, and you guys have a real gem of a waitress named Rosa. She's absolutely fantastic and does a phenomenal job all across the board. She's most definitely an ASSET to your company, she deserves some recognition. My family wanted to eat at your other location around the corner but I said no, we had to come to this location because of Rosa and the service she provides along with the staff who has a hand in preparing and delivering the awesome food you guys have. Anyone who wants to have an unforgettable experience at Nicola Pizza, you ask for Rosa!

Great pizza, best pasta. Fries are also a requirement.

They have half-priced Nicobolis on Thursdays during the off-season. A great deal! Would strongly recommend. The service is wonderful.

Ordered to go food last night and the employee that handed me my pizza had the most disgusting fingernails and looked as if he hasn't bathed in a week. Gross. The pizza was also extremely greasy and gave me explosive diarrhea within hours of consuming it. Do not recommend.

Fast and decent although service could be better. Food was good though felt a bit rushed.

Must try nicoboli here!! The best

Best pizza in Rehoboth. Nice family atmosphere and world famous Nic-o-boli.

I have been going to Nicola Pizza my whole life! They have the best pizza and Nic-o-boli (strombolis) at the beach. My wife is in love with the Nic-spin-oli! Their street fries are right up there with all the other boardwalk fries. All their food tastes great with some good old birch beer. Great service and a community minded business.

Yummy,fresh food n great service every time we visit!

I know this spot has a following and as for being compared to other “boardwalk pizza places” it could be worse but we have found others that we liked more. It is an effort to find the best in this town.

Memories of the past. The food is just as good as it was in the 70's, got to sit in the window & reminisce with good friends. Loved it!

Every time I'm in the area I have to get a case of Nicobolis😍😍😍 We go through 8 or 9 cases a year and I could eat more! No others even compare.

I drive over 2 hours each way just to come here and get a nicoboli! They never disappoint. I even take home a case of frozen ones home!

Love coming here on vacation. Great mix of dough, sauce and cheese

My husband and I have been coming here since 1989. This “IS” the best pizza and Boli on the entire east coast. RIP mama Nicola. Miss her 💔

Love this place and their Nic-o-bolis! I stop here before I go home every year after a week at the beach or after race weekend. Good food and kind employees.

I used to be a huge fan of the other pizza that ya famous in Rehoboth beach but Nicolas won me over. The pizza is delicious and although it isn’t open that late, it is the perfect way to end your night.

Get the Nicoboli original ground beef version.Owner Nicky stops at each table to say hello.Great staff. They share tips, so keep that in mind as different wait staff come to see how you are doing. 🍕

It's always a great experience at Nicolas. I've been going there for 25 years and it remains consistently a great value and a solid meal.

My Boyfriend and I have been drivIng up from Maryland for Valentine’s Day weekend and couple time in the summer season we absolutely love this place and we love seeing all the familiar faces especially Amanda!! She works the bar typically downstairs she is a hard worker and we really appreciate her service! We come for the pizza, pasta, Orange Crushes and definitely stay for Staff!❤️ Did I mention the pizza! We always take a large one home lol

Food was just ok, so it was hard to overcome bad service. The biggest issue was the disorganization at the take out window. I ordered at the window, stood in line to pick up, sent to other window and told to pick up there. Stood in line there and then was told to go back to the first window. I stood in line again and when I got to the front IThe guy tried to send me back to the other window but I told him I already had, he got mad, went and got my order. Then ripped off the receipt and threw it in the trash and gave me my order with an attitude. I started walking away and luckily thought to look in the bag because there were no utensils in the bag (for spaghetti and a boli). I went back and asked for some and again he got an attitude while giving me the utensils. Good food can help overcome bad service, but the food wasn't that good, I was disappointed.

Even though I am a Philly kid and used to traditional stromboli the nicoboli was pretty good. Although I must say I enjoyed the pizza much more. Looking around the room everything looks so delicious from the GED to the cheese fries. The atmosphere was welcoming the staff was friendly a place I would recommend trying if you're in the area.

Get the Nicoboli! It's great. Large cheese fries are just that. LARGE. Like 3 people large. Very attentive waitress. Will definitely go back.

Stopped in after a day on the beach. Had a few slices and some happy hour drinks. We like pizza and we were pleasantly surprised. Pizza was great. Came out super fast. Angelo was our server/tender and he is one of the best around. Will be back for many trips.

Their white pizza is the best and the young guy who took our order was so so sweet and friendly!! Get pizza here every year!!

Beyond great food! Locally owned for decades. The Nicoboli is a must!

Yummy as usual. Mini pizza and a dogfish. Can't get much better than that. Coping with covid well.

One of my favorite restaurants on the planet earth. I've been eating here every summer since I was a kid, and the food and service is as amazing as it was 30+ years ago. If you've never had a Nic-O-Boli, you've never truly lived!!!! Fries and salad are also great!

Still one of the best.

Yummy and affordable especially for the location. Friendly staff!

Nicola Pizza has been at Rehoboth Beach since 1971. They started on a cross street and now have a major presence on Rehoboth Ave.I knew it from the early 70’s and remember the tables at the windows on both sides of the door. They’re still there. It’s like window shopping watching people dine.Of the three major pizza providers, I would rate Nicola’s at #2 (Grottos a disappointing #3 when they were the first and best back in the day and Louie’s is #1).Nicola’s pizza is a cheese lover’s delight. Their price per slice is less than Grottos and more than Louie’s.I didn’t have their famous and touted Nic-o-boli, but I’m sure it’s well worth the hype.